Buying every domain extension "for protection" costs $150-300/year for domains you'll never use. Most businesses only need 1-2 domains. Choose based on where your customers are, not paranoia about competitors.
The Only Extensions That Matter
.com still dominates global commerce. 52% of websites use .com. Users type .com instinctively. If your domain isn't .com, you lose traffic to whoever owns the .com version.
Country TLDs matter IN that country. .co.uk dominates UK. .de dominates Germany. .com.au dominates Australia. Locals trust their country extension more than .com for local businesses.
The .com Default
Global business selling worldwide: .com mandatory. No alternative builds same trust. Users won't remember .io, .co, .app unless your brand is already famous.
If YourBrand.com is taken: Change your brand name. Buying a .io or .co alternative means fighting user behavior forever. They'll type .com and land on someone else's site.
When .com Isn't Critical
You only serve one country: Country TLD acceptable. UK-only business can use .co.uk as primary. German business can use .de. Customers won't expect .com.
Niche tech product: .io, .ai, .dev acceptable for developer tools. GitHub uses github.com but dev.to works because developers understand TLDs. General public still expects .com.
The typing test: Ask 10 people to find your website. If 6+ type .com first, you need the .com. Don't force users to remember unusual extensions.
Country TLD Strategy
Operating in UK: Buy .co.uk AND .com. Use .co.uk as primary. Forward .com to .co.uk to catch US spellings and global searches. Prevents competitors squatting .com.
Operating in Germany: .de primary. Forward .com to .de. German users trust .de more than .com for local services (banks, insurance, healthcare).
ccTLD Trust Advantage
Country code TLDs (ccTLDs) signal local presence. .co.uk = British company. .de = German company. .com.au = Australian company. Builds trust faster than .com for local services.
Google treats ccTLDs as geo-targeted. .co.uk ranks better in UK searches. .de ranks better in German searches. .com treated as global - no geographic boost.
The Multi-Country Problem
Selling in UK, Germany, France, Spain: Do you need .co.uk, .de, .fr, .es AND .com? Depends on business model.
E-commerce approach: One .com site with language/currency selection. Forward all country TLDs to .com. Saves hosting/maintenance costs. Works if brand is consistent across countries.
Localized approach: Separate sites per country on country TLDs. .co.uk for UK customers, .de for German customers. Better local SEO but expensive to maintain. Only worth it if you have local teams/inventory per country.
The Forwarding Strategy
Buy country TLDs to prevent squatting. Forward all to primary .com (or primary country TLD). User types YourBrand.de, lands on YourBrand.com with German language option. Costs €10-15/year per domain to maintain forwards. Cheap protection.
Don't forward TO a different brand. If you use .io as primary, forwarding .com to .io confuses users. They see .io in browser and wonder if it's a scam. Primary domain should be what users expect.
Forward all secondary domains TO your primary domain. Don't use multiple domains simultaneously - splits SEO value, confuses customers, complicates branding. One primary domain for all traffic.
New gTLDs (.io, .ai, .app)
Tech companies love .io (input/output, sounds tech). Google loves .ai (artificial intelligence). .app for mobile apps. Do they work?
.io success cases: Itch.io (gaming), Socket.io (developers), Notion.so (productivity). Works when targeting developers or tech early adopters who understand TLDs.
.io failures: Consumer products trying .io because .com was taken. Users type .com, land on squatter site, never find you. 40% traffic loss measured for consumer .io sites.
Who Can Use New TLDs
Developer tools, open source projects, API services: .io, .dev work. Your users are tech-savvy. They won't default to .com.
AI/ML products: .ai acceptable. Signals product category. But .com still safer if available. Anthropic uses anthropic.com not anthropic.ai (though they probably own both).
Mobile apps: .app works if app name is unique. "MyApp.app" clearer than "MyApp.com". But if app becomes web service later, you'll want .com anyway.
SEO Impact of Extensions
Google officially treats all gTLDs equally. .com, .io, .app, .xyz - same SEO value in theory. Practice: .com sites get more backlinks because users trust them more. Trust → links → SEO.
Country TLDs get geographic boost. .co.uk ranks better in UK, .de in Germany. But ONLY in that country. .co.uk won't rank well in US searches. .com ranks globally.
The Backlink Effect
Users more likely to link to .com sites. "Looks more legitimate." .xyz or .club domains get fewer organic backlinks even with identical content. Affects long-term SEO.
News sites, bloggers, directories prefer linking to .com or country TLDs. .io acceptable for tech content. But .xyz, .club, .online treated as suspicious even if legitimate.
Link discrimination is real: A/B test showed .com domains get 34% more unsolicited backlinks than .io equivalents with same content. Choose extension that maximizes natural link-building.
Protection Strategy
How many extensions to buy for "protection"? Minimum: Your primary extension + .com (if .com isn't primary).
Reasonable protection: Primary + .com + major country TLDs you operate in. UK business: .co.uk primary + .com + maybe .eu. Costs $30-50/year total.
Excessive protection: All possible extensions (.net, .org, .biz, .info, country TLDs you don't operate in). Costs $150-300/year. Wastes money unless you're a major brand.
Typo Domains
Should you buy common misspellings? (e.g., YourBrand.com + YourBrand.net + YorBrand.com + YourBrnad.com).
Small business: No. Not worth cost. Users who misspell will Google you, not type domains. Large brand: Maybe YourBrand.net/.org to catch typos. But don't buy 20 variations.
When to Buy Multiple Domains
Rebranding: Changing YourOldBrand.com to YourNewBrand.com. Buy both, forward old to new for 2-3 years during transition. Prevents customer confusion.
Product lines: YourBrand.com for company + YourProduct.com for major product. Works if product has independent identity (e.g., Google owns google.com and youtube.com). Small businesses rarely need this.
Campaigns: Temporary campaign domain (SpecialOffer.com → YourBrand.com/offer). Only worth it if campaign is major and domain is memorable. Usually waste of money - campaigns work fine on subdirectories.
Multiple domains only make sense for large companies with distinct product lines. Small businesses should use one domain with clear navigation. YourBrand.com/product1 beats Product1.com for SEO and branding.
Email Extension Considerations
Your website is .io but you use [email protected] for business. Mismatched domains confuse customers. They wonder if email is legitimate.
Best practice: Email domain matches website domain. Website is YourBrand.io → Email is [email protected]. Consistency builds trust.
The .com Email Override
Website is .co.uk (UK business) but CEO uses [email protected] because .com "feels more professional." Splits brand. Customers confused whether to visit .com or .co.uk.
Solution: Email matches primary domain. UK site on .co.uk = email on .co.uk. German site on .de = email on .de. Reinforces local presence.
Extension Costs
.com: $10-15/year. .co.uk: £10-15/year. .de: €10-15/year. .io: $35-60/year. .ai: $60-120/year (expensive due to hype). .app: $15-25/year.
Bulk buying extensions: Don't fall for "register 10 extensions for $99/year" deals. You'll renew 10 extensions forever. Only buy what you'll use or forward.
Hidden Renewal Costs
Registrars offer .com first year for $0.99, then renew at $15-20/year. Always check renewal pricing. Switching registrars later is annoying.
Premium domains: Short/common words cost $500-5,000+ to register even on new TLDs. "AI.ai" was $1,000+ to register. "Data.io" was $800+. Renewal stays normal ($35-60) after first year.
Renewal trap: Buying 5 extensions "for protection" costs $50-75 first year. Renewal every year costs $50-75 indefinitely. After 10 years you've spent $500-750 on forwards you never needed. Buy only what you'll actively use or truly need for brand protection.
Brandable Domain Shortage
All good .com domains taken. Do you buy a bad .com or a good .io?
Bad .com beats good .io for consumer businesses. Example: "CloudSyncPro.com" (long, awkward) beats "Clo.io" (short, clever). Users default to .com regardless of quality.
Good .io beats bad .com for tech/developer products. Developers appreciate short, clever .io domains. "api.io" beats "APIIntegrationSystem.com" for developer tool.
The Hyphen Question
YourBrand.com taken. Buy Your-Brand.com with hyphen? Generally no. Users won't remember the hyphen. They'll type YourBrand.com, land on competitor.
Exception: If competitor's YourBrand.com is parked/unused AND your brand has natural hyphen (e.g., "North-West Logistics" could be North-West.com). But usually signals weak brand name.
The 5-Year Test
Ask: "Will I still want this domain in 5 years?" For your primary domain: Yes, choose carefully. For "protective" registration: Probably not, skip it.
Domains you'll actually use: Company site, product sites, campaign domains you plan to maintain long-term. Budget for renewals.
Domains you won't use: Random country TLDs "just in case." Typo variants. Unusual extensions that seemed clever but don't fit brand. Let them expire.
Trademark Lens checks domain availability across all major extensions simultaneously - so you can make informed decisions about which domains actually matter for your brand.