Exact-match domains (BestPlumberNYC.com) ranked higher in 2010. Google's 2012 EMD update changed everything. Now branded domains (Handy.com) outperform keyword domains 73% of the time. Brand wins.
The EMD Era (2005-2012)
Exact-match domains dominated SEO. "ChicagoLocksmith.com" ranked #1 for "Chicago locksmith" regardless of content quality. Domain name = instant rankings.
Problem: Spam. Low-quality sites with exact-match domains outranked quality brands. Google's solution: EMD algorithm update (September 2012). Devalued low-quality exact-match domains.
Current EMD Value
Exact-match domains STILL provide minor SEO benefit (5-10% boost) IF combined with quality content, backlinks, user engagement. But keyword alone won't rank you.
"NYCPlumber.com" with thin content = no rankings. "NYCPlumber.com" with expert content, reviews, backlinks = slight advantage over "RotoRooter.com" (brand name).
Brand Authority Signals
Google now prioritizes: Brand searches (people searching "YourBrand"). Direct traffic (typing YourBrand.com). Branded backlinks ("as seen on YourBrand"). Social mentions. These beat exact-match keywords.
Build brand, SEO follows. Chase exact-match domain, you're stuck with unmemorable name AND minimal SEO benefit.
Brands with strong brand searches achieve 4.2x higher organic traffic vs exact-match domains with no brand recognition. "Warby Parker" (branded) beats "CheapGlassesOnline" (keyword-stuffed) in every metric.
Partial Match Strategy
Compromise: Brand name + keyword. "SquareSpace" (Square + Space = subtle real estate/web space reference). "MailChimp" (Mail = email, but Chimp = brandable).
Gets: Slight keyword relevance + strong brand identity. Avoids: Generic exact-match trap.
The Compound Advantage
Two-word brands where one word = industry keyword. "HubSpot" (Hub = marketing hub). "Salesforce" (Sales = CRM). Keyword hidden in brandable name.
Best of both: Brand memorability + subtle SEO signal. USPTO approves (not merely descriptive). Customers remember (distinctive branding).
Local Business Exception
Local service businesses (plumbers, lawyers, dentists) STILL benefit from geo + keyword domains. "AustinRoofing.com" helps local SEO for "Austin roofing" searches.
But: Brand still matters. "AustinRoofing.com" + brand name "Longhorn Roofing" = local SEO + brand recall. Domain supports brand, doesn't replace it.
Google My Business Priority
For local businesses: Google My Business optimization beats domain keywords 10:1. Verified GMB listing + reviews + NAP consistency = local rankings. Domain name = minor factor.
Focus: Build brand, optimize GMB, earn reviews. Domain keyword relevance = nice-to-have, not must-have.
Hyphenated Domains
"Best-Plumber-NYC.com" vs "BestPlumberNYC.com" vs "JoesPlumbing.com." Hyphens make exact-match more explicit BUT hurt user experience.
Problems: Users forget hyphens (type BestPlumberNYC.com, land on competitor). Looks spammy. Harder to verbally communicate. Voice search fails (Alexa/Siri ignore hyphens).
Hyphenated domains lose 35% direct traffic to non-hyphenated versions. User types yourbrand.com, competitor owns it. You lose customer. Never use hyphens unless absolutely necessary.
New TLD Strategy
.plumbing, .dentist, .lawyer, .tech = industry-specific TLDs. Do they help SEO? Google says "TLD doesn't affect rankings." Reality: Minimal impact.
Benefit: Keyword in TLD (YourBrand.plumbing). Drawback: Users default to .com (forget .plumbing extension, can't find you).
The .com Bias
67% of users type .com automatically. "YourBrand.plumbing" requires user to remember non-.com extension. Most won't. Lost traffic.
Use industry TLDs ONLY if: Exact brand.com unavailable. You run heavy branding campaign educating users on extension. Otherwise, stick .com.
Domain Age Myth
"Older domains rank better." Partially true. Domain age = proxy for established brand authority, backlink profile, content history. But NEW domain with great content can outrank 10-year-old domain with poor content.
Focus: Build authority (content, backlinks, engagement), not wait for domain age. One year of aggressive SEO beats ten years of dormancy.
Buying Aged Domains
Buying expired domains with backlinks? Risky. If previous owner was spammy, domain carries penalty. Google maintains spam history. Inherited penalty kills your SEO.
Check: Wayback Machine (archive.org) for previous site content. Ahrefs/Moz for backlink quality. Spammy history = avoid. Clean history = potential value.
Exact Match for PPC
Exact-match domains help paid search (Google Ads) more than organic SEO. "BestInsuranceQuotes.com" in Google Ads gets higher Quality Score for "best insurance quotes" keywords.
Higher Quality Score = lower CPC. If running heavy PPC, exact-match domain saves 10-20% on ad spend. But organic SEO benefits minimal.
PPC-focused businesses benefit from exact-match domains (lower CPC). Organic SEO-focused businesses benefit from branded domains (authority building). Know your acquisition strategy before choosing domain.
Voice Search Impact
Alexa: "Find best plumber NYC." Does "BestPlumberNYC.com" rank? No. Google ranks based on reviews, content quality, local signals. Domain name irrelevant for voice search.
Voice search prioritizes: Google My Business, featured snippets, question-answer content. Brand name in result = user remembers. Keyword domain = generic, forgettable.
The Memorability Factor
User hears recommendation: "Use Handy for plumbing" (brand name, memorable) vs "Use BestPlumberNYC" (generic, forgotten). Branded domains win word-of-mouth marketing.
Voice search era rewards brands people remember and recommend. Exact-match domains = transactional, not memorable.
International SEO
Expanding globally? Exact-match English domain doesn't work in France. "BestPlumber.com" meaningless to French speakers. "Handy.com" (brand) works anywhere.
Keyword domains lock you to one language/market. Branded domains scale globally. Plan for growth, choose brand.
The Rebranding Cost
Start with "NYCPlumber.com," grow beyond NYC, rebrand to "TruePlumbing.com." Lose: All domain authority, backlinks to old domain, brand recognition. Cost: $50K-250K.
Choose brandable domain from day 1. Avoids expensive rebrand when you outgrow geographic/keyword limitation. "Uber" scales globally. "NYCRideShare" wouldn't.
Trademark Lens helps evaluate domain names for both trademark protection and brand scalability - ensuring your domain choice supports long-term growth, not just short-term SEO.